Welcome to Yoder's, a Sarasota tradition since 1975! Since first opening it's doors, Yoder's has been synonymous with Mom's homemade Amish pies and hearty portions of great home cooking served with fast, friendly service in a family atmosphere.
Yoder's Restaurant has been serving Amish food since 1975. It is difficult to decide which is best, the pies or the fried chicken. Yum!
Yoder's Deli is the newest addition to Yoder's Amish Village. Yoder's Deli serves fresh deli meats, cheeses and great tasting bulk foods.
Yoder's Fresh Market serves only the freshest Florida produce. You can find all in- season produce here at great prices.
Yoder's Gift Shop offers gifts that are unique to the Amish culture. These items are sure to be a hit as a gift or in your kitchen...
Welcome to Yoder's Amish Village
Welcome to Yoder's, a Sarasota tradition since 1975! Since first opening it's doors, Yoder's has been synonymous with Mom's homemade Amish pies and hearty portions of great home cooking served with fast, friendly service in a family atmosphere. Yoder's Amish Restaurant has been a long time favorite with local residents, voted first place by the People's Choice awards (Sarasota Herald Tribune & Channel 40) for:
• Best Dinner Under $10.00
• Best Amish Restaurant
• Best Homemade Desserts
• Best Key Lime Pie
• Best Carry out
• Best Breakfast
Yoder's continues to be a destination spot for people far and near and continues to serve up the most delicious Amish home cooking experience you've ever tasted. Guaranteed! See you soon...
Hear what our customers are saying...
"I miss Yoder's SO much! They have the best fried chicken ever!" - Portland, OR
"Wonderful food! Wonderful service! Wonderful hospitality! Wonderful cleanliness! And, the most amazing pies you will find anywhere!"- Okatie, SC
"the best pie on the planet, try the peanut butter..." - Tampa, FL
"Their fried chicken is awesome! The portion sizes are very generous. The chocolate peanut butter pie is to die for!!" - Florida
View Kid's Menu
** Because we want to guarantee you the best service possible, we can not accept online orders. Please call and place all orders.
Here is a tip for rolling out pie dough! I recently discovered if you roll the dough out between two pieces of waxed paper, when the crust is the proper size, just peel the top piece of waxed paper off the dough. Easy as pie ( no pun intended).