• Fried Chicken Dinner by Yoder's Restaurant in Sarasota.

    Yoder's Famous Fried Chicken

    Country cooking Southern style. All-natural chicken, hand breaded and deep pressure fried to seal in the juices and give it a crispy texture outside.
    Customers’ favorite, hands down!

    Fried Chicken Dinner by Yoder's Restaurant in Sarasota.

     

  • Amish gift shop by Yoder's Amish Restaurant in Pinecraft Village in Sarasota,FL

    Welcome!

    Welcome to Yoder's, a Sarasota tradition since first opening it's doors in 1975! From day one, Yoder's has been known for "Mom's" homemade Amish pies and made from scratch home cooking. Hearty portions served with fast and friendly service in a family atmosphere. Yoder's has been a long time local favorite. Stop in, we're sure you will love our meals, Gift Shop, Produce Market, Deli Market and our award winning pies!

  • Order your Easter pies at Yoder's Restaurant in Sarasota, FL

    Order your
    Easter Pies Today!!

    Delicious homemade baked or cream pies from Yoder's Restaurant to complete your Easter Dinner. Please have your order placed by Friday, April 18th. Easter pies may be picked up outside by the bakery window, on the north side of building 9am-6pm Saturday, April 19.
    Easter Pie Menu >>

  • Award winning Amish peanut butter pie by Yoder's Restaurant in Sarasota, FL


    Peanut Butter Pie

    Nationally recognized on the Travel Channel.

    Award winning Amish peanut butter pie by Yoder's Restaurant in Sarasota, FL

  • Raspberry Stuffed French Toast the best breakfast by Yoder's Amish Restaurant in Pinecraft Village in Sarasota,FL

    Raspberry Stuffed French Toast

    Thick sliced bread, grilled golden brown and stuffed with cream cheese and raspberry filling.

    view best amish breakfast in Pinecraft village in Sarasota,Fl by Yoder's Amish Restaurant

  • Amish traditional eggs benedict by Yoder's Amish Restaurant in Pinecraft Village in Sarasota,Fl

    Traditional Benedict

    Toasted English muffin topped with thin
    sliced country ham, two soft basted eggs
    and hollandaise sauce, served with home fries

    view best amish breakfast in Pinecraft village in Sarasota,Fl by Yoder's Amish Restaurant

Welcome to Yoder's Amish Village

Levi & Amanda Yoder Founders of Yoder's Amish Restaurant in Sarasota,Fl also known as Pinecraft
Welcome to Yoder's, a Sarasota tradition since first opening it's doors in 1975! From day one, Yoder's has been known for "Mom's" homemade Amish pies and made from scratch home cooking.  Hearty portions served with fast and friendly service in a family atmosphere. Yoder's has been a long time local favorite. Stop in, we're sure you will love our meals, Gift Shop, Produce Market, Deli Market and our award winning pies!

 



Hear what our customers are saying...


Found this Amish Village by accident. Which had a fresh produce market gift shop restaurant and deli. Stopped in while traveling from Ocala to Cape Coral ate at Yoder’s. The staff was very friendly and the food was excellent. I had the fried chicken special and hubby had the stuffed cabbage special. Both diners were very good homemade and very fresh, portions were large. Couldn't leave without taking fresh pies and cakes back with us. - Ocala, Florida



We visited having seen this on Man V Food and so glad we did. Portions were insane, fried chicken was absolutely amazing, sides delicious I.e. fried okra and mashed potatoes with gravy! Lived up to and beyond expectations. Took a slice each of cherry pie and peanut butter pie home with us as we had to try them and they were gorgeous also! Would recommend! Great shop selling produce near by too!




We enjoyed an amazing meatloaf sandwich at this place... wow,,, were the portions large. My husband and I came in for just a snack and the size of the sandwich was large enough for 2 people. the best Meat Loaf Sandwich ever eaten. The coffee was great and the sugar-free apple pie was the best ever eaten. We definitely recommend this place to anyone to visit. Enjoyed our visit in the Produce Market, Deli and Gift Shop... always come out with something interesting and enjoyable. The staff throughout was very friendly and helpful and just pleasant to visit with.. Will come again when in the area and will recommend to others! -Winnipeg, Canada.



 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Yoder's Gift Card
The Perfect Gift!

Yoder's Restaurant Gift Cards, the gift everyone will enjoy

Buy your gift card in any amount online and we will send it to you via USPS. Don't have a Pay Pal account? No worries, use any major credit card.

View Our Menu

Delicious Amish Home style cookin' from Yoder's Amish Restaurant in Sarasota,FlDaily Specials

Breakfast Menu

Lunch & Dinner Menu

Pie Menu

Easter Pie Menu

Kid's Menu

** Because we want to guarantee you the best service possible, we can not accept online orders. Please call and place all orders.

Pinecraft -
Florida's Amish Community

Visiting Pinecraft

Katie's Blog

Sarasota's Best...

Referrals for Yoders Amish Restaurant Known for their Amish fried chicken and award winning pies in Sarasota ,Fl
Online Referrals & Articles

yelp! | Trip Advisor | Google Places

 

Want to be part of our family?

Facebook for Yoder's Restaurant and Fresh market in Sarasota